Only 16 Haredi draft dodgers arrested so far this year, AG tells top Israeli court

Ahead of a proposed 90-day arrest freeze for yeshiva students, the IDF warns that the country is on its way to 90,000 Haredi draft dodgers

Haaretz
75
6 мин чтения
0 просмотров
Only 16 Haredi draft dodgers arrested so far this year, AG tells top Israeli court

Current section

  1. Israel News
  2. Israel Political News

Ahead of a proposed 90-day arrest freeze for yeshiva students, the IDF warns that the country is on its way to 90,000 Haredi draft dodgers

Border Police officers disperse an ultra-Orthodox demonstration against arrests of Haredi IDF draft evaders in Jerusalem, earlier this month. Credit: Itay Cohen
Border Police officers disperse an ultra-Orthodox demonstration against arrests of Haredi IDF draft evaders in Jerusalem, earlier this month. Credit: Itay Cohen

04:16 AM • July 01 2026 IDT

Between January 16 and June 11, 2026, 165 conscription-eligible Israelis declared deserters or draft dodgers were arrested in proactive military police operations, but only 16 were from the ultra-Orthodox community, Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara told the High Court of Justice on Tuesday. Another 81 deserters were detained by police in random encounters and transferred to the military police.

The data was submitted to the High Court in the attorney general's response to petitions demanding the enforcement of a landmark ruling that mandates the enlistment of ultra-Orthodox men and imposes sanctions on draft dodgers. According to the figures, 294 indictments were filed between January and mid-June against draft dodgers who exceeded the criminal threshold. The military prosecution estimates that 32 of them are ultra-Orthodox. Meanwhile, some 80,000 ultra-Orthodox men have not enlisted but do not yet meet the 540-day non-appearance threshold required for criminal prosecution.

As of May 10, Baharav-Miara noted, Israel had 92,080 designated conscripts who had been declared draft dodgers or issued an Order 12 – a desertion notice that becomes an arrest warrant after a month. According to Israel Defense Forces sources, approximately 80 percent of them are ultra-Orthodox.

"Regarding proactive enforcement against draft dodgers, military officials reported improved cooperation with the police, which will enable the army to carry out proactive operations, including arrests, in the near future," the attorney general's response stated. The agreement stipulates that proactive military police activity will only take place after operational coordination and approval from the local police station, and only if the station's routine manpower allows. Police officials emphasized that no assistance would be provided without prior planning and that the initiative must come from the IDF.

Meanwhile, the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee discussed an initiative today to freeze the arrests of deserting yeshiva students for three months. Under the proposal, all arrests, investigations or enforcement proceedings against designated conscripts who are Torah students would be halted for 90 days. A yeshiva student would be defined as someone studying at a yeshiva for at least 45 hours a week.

Haaretz Podcast

Haaretz Election Podcast Kickoff: How far will Netanyahu go to stay in power?

Haaretz Podcast

Haaretz Election Podcast Kickoff: How far will Netanyahu go to stay in power?

total-- : --time0:00

The defense minister would compile the list of eligible yeshivas based on criteria anchored in regulations and approved by the committee, taking into account recommendations from the Council of Yeshivas. If an inspector finds repeated non-attendance of 20 percent or more at a yeshiva, the head of the institution would receive a warning; a recurrence would lead to the yeshiva's removal from the list. The bill remains vague on the number of inspectors, stating it would be determined by the defense minister and approved by the committee.

Because temporary orders are automatically extended during an election period until the end of the first three months of the next Knesset's term, the proposed 90-day freeze would in practice last for at least six months.

Committee chairman MK Boaz Bismuth (Likud) said during the session that "as Cabinet Secretary Yossi Fuchs noted in his letter to the committee, the professional stance of officials on the ground ... is that a continued arrest policy could harm conscription efforts and reduce the actual number of conscripts. Arrests create the opposite of the desired effect." Bismuth added: "Our responsibility is to examine results, not just intentions. When reality shows that arrests deter young ultra-Orthodox men from serving, we must ask whether this approach serves the national interest."

MK Meir Porush of the United Torah Judaism party, right, with IDF Personnel Chief Shay Tayeb at a Knesset committee session on Haredi draft in December. Credit: Oren Ben Hakoon
MK Meir Porush of the United Torah Judaism party, right, with IDF Personnel Chief Shay Tayeb at a Knesset committee session on Haredi draft in December. Credit: Oren Ben Hakoon

Brig. Gen. Shai Tayeb, the head of the Manpower Directorate's Planning and Administration Division, countered that "enforcement tools, including arrests and imprisonment, are part of our ability to implement the Security Service Law." While he claimed an increase in ultra-Orthodox enlistment – predicting the number would pass 3,500 by the end of the year – Tayeb warned that "we are on our way to 90,000 draft dodgers."

In response, Jerusalem Affairs Minister Meir Porush called the figure "a tremendous achievement on this table, tremendous." Tayeb noted that a temporary order alone would not help, adding, "It could have negative effects. I think it fails to fulfill its purpose and compromises certain interests."

The committee's legal counsel criticized the proposal on Monday, writing that it "attempts to create a bypass route designed to circumvent the need for a legislative arrangement to regulate the status of yeshiva students." The counsel warned that the arrangement would legitimize future draft dodgers, "providing them with prior immunity and granting them protection against criminal proceedings."

In the News

Emergency services in northern Israel's Yagur on Wednesday morning.

Three Israelis Killed Within a Single Hour Across Country as Homicides Skyrocket

A fragment of scroll: New project could elucidate the source of the materials

EU Funding Huge Project on the Origins of the Dead Sea Scrolls

Gwyneth Paltrow at a fashion event in New York City. Ever since October 7, she has emerged as a prominent voice for Israel and the Jewish people.

Jews Like Gwyneth Paltrow Deserve Better From the State of Israel

Melat Kiros participates in a League of Women Voters Congressional District 1 candidate forum at Montview Presbyterian Church on May 28, 2026, in Denver.

Israel Critic Wins in Major Upset as Democrats' Progressive Wave Hits Colorado

פותחת

Court: Israel Police Violated Law by Inviting TV Crew to Film Raid on Minors

POG - POWER OF GIVING  2025

Remembering and rebuilding two years later

ICYMI

Qatar's emir arrives in Algeria, March 2024. In red: An Elbit defense system.

Advanced Israeli Systems Sold to Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Documents and Images Show

Israel 2026 Election Poll Tracker: The Latest Projections

Mental injured soldiers and citizens in Israel

A Collapsing Society: Israel Suffers National Mental Crisis Due to the War

Serbian Member of the Presidency of Bosnia and Herzegovina Željka Cvijanović and  Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu meet at the prime minister's office on Monday.

FlagGate: How Israel Set Off a Storm by Hosting a Separatist Genocide Denier

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani embracing Brad Lander after the latter won the Democratic nomination for NY-10, in Brooklyn on Tuesday.

Why Israelis Should Stop Being Afraid of Mamdani-backed Brad Lander

פותחת

Settlers Tried to Torch Palestinian Homes. They Messed With the Wrong Village

Оригинальный источник

Haaretz

Поделиться статьей

Похожие статьи

The Somme, 110 years on: The Jewish soldiers who fought and died
🇮🇱🇵🇸Israel vs Palestine
The Jerusalem Post

The Somme, 110 years on: The Jewish soldiers who fought and died

The Battle of the Somme, one of the bloodiest and most infamous battles in history, was intended to break the German lines and bring World War I closer to an Allied victory.

около 1 часа назад8 min
Gaza war could have ended a year earlier, achieved more Hamas disarmament, ex-hostage chief says
🇮🇱🇵🇸Israel vs Palestine
The Jerusalem Post

Gaza war could have ended a year earlier, achieved more Hamas disarmament, ex-hostage chief says

An overlong war led to huge unnecessary losses in fallen soldiers and the death of up to 40 hostages, former lead hostage negotiations coordinator Maj.-Gen. (res.) Nitzan Alon said.

около 1 часа назад3 min
Israel sanctions IRGC-linked crypto accounts funneling millions to Hezbollah, other proxies
🇮🇱🇵🇸Israel vs Palestine
The Jerusalem Post

Israel sanctions IRGC-linked crypto accounts funneling millions to Hezbollah, other proxies

These funds, totaling approximately NIS 24 million, were used to fund various Iranian terror proxies, including Hezbollah.

около 2 часов назад2 min
Suspected terrorist shot after attempting to stab Israel Police officer, officer not injured
🇮🇱🇵🇸Israel vs Palestine
The Jerusalem Post

Suspected terrorist shot after attempting to stab Israel Police officer, officer not injured

The police officer, who was part of the Israel Police's Special Patrol Unit (YASAM), was not injured.

около 2 часов назад1 min